4ward: If you don’t really give a damn about writing, or reading about the activity of writing, or life and The Bigger Picture in particular, I suggest you avoid reading this post. You might just want to check out Perez Hilton for the latest gossip, and I say this without condescension because alas! it is also my guilty pleasure. If you aren’t a P.H fan, I’m sure there are tons of YouTube videos you could catch up on.
A Personal Reaction to Kathleen Alcott’s Essay “From Shrinking Solid to Expanding Gas: A Writer’s Life” and my general angst
Writing has always been romantic for me; first grader afternoons during creative writing hour, my hands would be cramped and screaming because of how hard I pressed my words onto the page with a definite meaning. A little too methodical for a dreamy writer; I had a serious attitude from the brilliance of story-making or the particularities of my own handwriting– the period has to be heavy, a finale to the sentence. The worlds I could create were only anchored by my elementary scrawl; it was the only way to make it know to people how my favorite koala character precisely felt, lived, and breathed.
The best of my writing has always been at the height of keen emotional turmoil—the pressures of my feelings make the flow of ink on paper more fluid, natural, precise; and so my biggest fear has always been the lack of these pressures to write, to feel. My romance in writing then relies on actual thinking, feeling, and experience in life. For me, the fuel for a writer becomes their role as a transient poet of experiences—they are able to live through an intense depth of emotion, from the dizzying heights of happiness to the abyss of depression and heartbreak. They bring these fields of gravity to an audience whose throats catch on the enunciation of abandonment, courage, or guilt that they themselves did survive. The story of a good author becomes a reader’s nearly-lived reality as the author’s guilt becomes the readers confession, and the author’s sadness lies in the reader’s tears.
With Kathleen Alcott’s essay, this role of a writer as a transient poet of experiences proves itself in the concrete intensity of her relationship with her father and how it has affected the rest of her life:
“Like him and every writer I’ve ever met, I’m driven by the love of a story that, in growing older, I’ve realized I have to monitor and constantly evaluate. I’m aware I have a proclivity for bringing people into my life not for their kindness or essential integrity, but for details I find compelling and weave into chains that don’t always, well, make sense. I have a hard time saying no to situations that will prove indelibly memorable.”
My mind then creates a gap of nothingness between the “heaviness” of her being with that of my own. It parallels the gap of shame that abruptly swallows me up when I’m wallowing in self-pity. That I’m HIV-free, that I can be assured of my next meal, or that I possess a privileged educational experience at a four year university becomes my shame– it isn’t quite the productive fuel I’m looking for, and I am once again at a loss for words (literally). I recently confessed to a close friend that “ i am desperately afraid I will become nothing, it’s so cliché”, and even with his trusted reassurances, I’m still desperately afraid that the safe life I have lead thus far is a sign of an unbearable lightness of being*. Blatantly put, I am a mediocre success amongst my peers; there are those whose resume should be fairly knit with gold stars and gold-er praises of dedication, exemplary character, and genius.
What is more disturbing, perhaps—beyond my personal crisis to seek a way to live, or a mission to feel the keenest of emotions, take the most shocking of risks in order to write better, is the compulsion to give myself that mission. Isn’t life supposed to be lead for experience, rather than the myopic nature of improving one craft? Is life lead to improve a soul and how is this improvement measured? By wealth, value, salary? Or how many successful children we have birthed into this world? Why is it that I need to figuratively bleed tears or laugh my heart dead to feel alive, and to make my writing all the more believable? And why do I feel mediocre, and why does mediocre feel bad?
Alcott’s Pulitzer-nominated father, David Lee Alcott, held his last job as a cashier at a gas station, his mental being suspended in disbelief at the life he had led up until then:
“He wrote that he should have died many different ways many years before, and so even walking half a block in the sun, without falling down, without having to take a break, with the thoughts of his whole life behind him, felt so glorious it made him shiver and weep.”
It is not with the worry of wealthy trappings that I review these words in dread. I realize that I am afraid, that I am weak. I feel I am too weak to try these life-bending memories on for size, which is why I have the time to ponder and argue the compulsion at all. Will I spend the rest of my days quibbling with my reflection? I am too afraid for love, for heartbreak, for happiness; too weak to show vulnerability, too weak to shore up the distance between me and another. I am too weak to commit and weave my existence with an idea that I fear is too good for me, too cool, too smart. I can stand back and tell myself that I would be good at anything at all, but it will never happen until the follow-through.
As for the worries concerning the compulsions to feel the utmost limits of human emotional range, or the speed at which I should climb the corporate ladder to achieve socially acceptable success, “I have no [GIVEN] mission. No one has”** — and the lack of knowing what I want has only become a cancerous counterproductive plague because I’ve talked myself out of actually experiencing what I do or do not want.
Simply put, I must spend less energy thinking about living and more energy into living; and I won’t have to press the lead down so hard for the words to scratch themselves into being.
By Grace Yang
August 5, 2010
Taipei, Taiwan
*for those who have not read Milan Kundera’s book, a favorite quote of mine sums the idea up quite nicely: “But is heaviness truly deplorable and lightness splendid?
The heaviest of burdens crushes us, we sink beneath it, it pins us to the ground. But in the love poetry of every age, the woman longs to be weighted down by the man’s body. The heaviest of burdens is therefore simultaneously an image of life’s most intense fulfillment.” Pg. 5
** Another quote from Kundera’s Being. The word in brackets, however, is my own.
Alcott, Kathleen. “From Shrinking Solid to Expanding Gas: The Writer’s Life.” The Rumpus 19 July 2010. therumpus.net. Web. 5 Aug. 2010.
Kundera, Milan. The Unbearable Lightness of Being: A Novel. New York: Harper Perennial Modern Classics, 2009. Print.